The Q Factor
Quantitative & Qualitative Analysis
Home
Blog
Blog
Research and analysis insights from reading annual reports
Research
Data-driven findings
Mainfreight: High Delivery Rate but Credibility Dropped. Here's Why.
40 commitments tracked. 16 delivered. 23 partial. The story is in the partials.
NZX
Industrials
4 min read
Does Management Credibility Predict Stock Returns?
2,003 company-year observations across US, ASX, SGX and NZX suggest it does. STRONG-rated companies returned +26.3% over 3 years. WEAK returned +0.7%.
ASX
NZX
SGX
Research
5 min read
Education
Learn the fundamentals
How to Read Annual Reports: A Practical Guide
Discover the 5 sections that reveal the most about a company's future.
10 min read
What is Management Credibility?
Learn how to evaluate whether CEOs deliver on their promises.
9 min read
Altman Z-Score Explained
Predicting bankruptcy risk using five financial ratios.
8 min read
Understanding Risk Disclosures
The most honest section of annual reports—and what to look for.
9 min read
Annual Report Red Flags: 7 Warning Signs Most Investors Miss
What 3,800+ annual report analyses across four exchanges reveal about the patterns that precede poor performance.
ASX
NZX
SGX
9 min read
Methodology
How we analyse
What 6,500 Tracked Commitments Reveal About Management Promises Across Four Exchanges
Financial promises get delivered most. Project timelines run late. Some just vanish.
ASX
NZX
SGX
US
5 min read
The Say/Do Ratio: Measuring Whether Management Means What It Says
How tracking management promises against delivery reveals the investment signal most investors miss.
Methodology
10 min read
9 Years, 76 Commitments: What Woodside's Annual Reports Actually Show
25 of 39 recent commitments delivered. Rated MODERATE for nine consecutive years.
ASX
Energy
5 min read
When Management Promises Don't Match Results: ASX Say/Do Gaps
Goodman Group delivered 5 of 27 commitments. Orica delivered 12 of 35.
ASX
Analysis
4 min read
Management Accountability: Why Tracking Commitments Matters
What 16,000 tracked commitments across 590+ companies reveal about management quality.
10 min read
The Management Commitment Framework
How we categorise what companies promise and why the patterns matter.
9 min read
How to Read Management Promises
Where to look, what to extract, and how to track delivery in five steps.
8 min read
Management Credibility Explained
Tracking what management promises versus what they deliver.
9 min read
Why Qualitative Analysis Matters
What numbers alone cannot tell you about a company.
10 min read
Quantitative vs Qualitative Analysis
Two approaches to stock research—automated metrics vs in-depth qualitative analysis.
5 min read
Our Analysis Process
How we systematically read and score annual reports.
8 min read
Market Insights
Patterns across markets
Same Brand, Different Businesses: What Coca-Cola's Two Tickers Reveal About Management Execution
KO owns the recipe. COKE runs the trucks. Both rate MODERATE. The annual reports tell different stories.
US
Consumer
4 min read
The Companies That Have Been MODERATE for Their Entire History
Amcor: 11 years. Woodside: 9. Spotify: 8. When a rating never changes, it stops being a phase.
ASX
NZX
SGX
US
5 min read
Viva Energy: When Management Delivers But the Numbers Don't Follow
Qual 76. Quant 40. Seven years. The widest divergence on the ASX.
ASX
Energy
4 min read
SGX's Highest-Rated Companies: Who's Scoring STRONG and Why
14 SGX companies in the top tier. DBS didn't make the cut. BRC Asia, VICOM, and Cortina lead.
SGX
Multi-sector
5 min read
SGX REITs: Who's Delivering on Debt Promises and Who Isn't
Arena REIT delivered 83% of commitments. Aims APAC REIT delivered 47%.
SGX
REITs
4 min read
NZX's Quiet Performers: The Companies Rated STRONG Right Now
Ten NZX companies rate in the top tier across 600+ companies on four exchanges.
NZX
Insights
3 min read
Does Your Company's Board Actually Understand Cybersecurity?
The Iran conflict elevated cybersecurity to essential utility status. Annual reports reveal which boards prepared and which are scrambling.
ASX
NZX
SGX
9 min read
The Data Behind the Crisis: What Annual Reports Reveal
ASX
NZX
SGX
9 min read
When Crisis Hits, Does Management Tell You the Truth?
The Strait of Hormuz crisis reveals which management teams told shareholders the truth — Woodside, Qantas, Air NZ, and SIA.
ASX
NZX
SGX
8 min read
NZX 2024: Management Trends
What 110 NZX annual reports reveal about credibility.
NZX
2024
10 min read
ASX 2024: Management Trends
What 194 ASX annual reports reveal about capital discipline.
ASX
2024
11 min read
SGX REITs: Forward Guidance Quality
What separates credible REIT managers from over-promisers.
SGX
REITs
10 min read
Weekly Market Movers
Volume-driven market commentary
Weekly Market Movers: Asx Ltd Leads with 4.8x Volume
ASX.AX volume surge — week of 25-29 May 2026. 17 commitments tracked.
ASX
Weekly
5 min read
Weekly Market Movers: Tuas Ltd Leads with 28.9x Volume
TUA.AX volume surge — week of 18-22 May 2026. 0 commitments tracked.
ASX
Weekly
5 min read
Weekly Market Movers: Bapcor Ltd Leads with 10.3x Volume
BAP.AX volume surge — week of 11-15 May 2026. 18 commitments tracked.
ASX
Weekly
5 min read
Weekly Market Movers: Gentrack Group Leads with 15.8x Volume
GTK.NZ volume surge — week of 4-8 May 2026. 18 commitments tracked.
NZX
Weekly
5 min read
Company Analysis
Deep dives
Fisher & Paykel Healthcare
5-year management track record—94% delivery rate.
NZX
Healthcare
9 min read
Northern Star Resources
Management credibility in a volatile sector—79% delivery.
ASX
Materials
12 min read
DBS Group
Forward guidance quality—87% delivery rate.
SGX
Financials
12 min read